Hello to all my Wonderful World Outside Our Window Subscribers,
This week, Deadline reported that Disney+ plans to bring TikTok videos to their streaming service by December, following up on a content-sharing deal with the short-form video platform announced back in August. Though details remain vague, it seems the streamer will be offering a selection of Disney-themed fan videos, curated through Disney’s Creator Ambassador program. The House of Mouse’s entry into the “User Generated Content” space is timed with the release of Avengers: Doomsday, a film that is likely to generate thousands of hours of reactions, theorizing, and of course complaints, from Marvel’s famously ferocious fanbase. Since audiences will have to wait a few months to watch Doomsday at home, the thinking here (I assume) is to give them an outlet to keep engaging with the fan-content already dominating the internet, but in a more Disney-approved way. Of course, they now also get to keep profiting off Doomsday immediately after audiences have returned home from the theater.
It’s the inherent profit extraction that makes me the most queasy about this deal. Although based on the general tenor of this blog and my use of the words “profit extraction” I imagine you can surmise my general views on “short form content,” it is not really the addition of such videos to the service that I take issue with. It is clear that in the war against Videos, I have simply lost, and that’s just the way it is. Earlier this year, when Disney started offering premium short-form content called, I swear to god, Verts, I barely blinked an eye. Whatever, we are all going to die anyways. But the idea that they can now host someone else’s videos, which they do not pay the person to create, is frankly galling.
The details of this Creator Ambassador program are sketchy, but from what I can tell, no money changes hands. Instead, the announced deal between Disney and TikTok will “enable best-in-class creators to unlock special rewards and provide them with increased visibility, access to exclusive events and career development pathways.” The program, which boasts a “tiered” reward system, does not compensate creators for their work, despite the fact that Disney+ is a paid platform. Although the videos will be available both on Disney+ and for free on TikTok, the announcement specifies that this is “at launch,” leading one to assume that these videos will eventually become exclusive to Disney+. This will then be a selling point for the streamer and (at least theoretically!), a driver of massive profits for Disney. While I’d be loath to assert that Disney currently pays the talent hosted on Disney+ well, at least they get, you know, paid. This seems to be a fairly clear-cut case of free labor, and talk of a reward system with certain tiers is quite dystopian to say the least. I reached out to Disney for comment on this, and did not receive a response. Shocking.
I find it hard to imagine that audiences are actually going to come to Disney+ for their short-form content needs, considering TikTok is free and creators on it maintain the appearance of independence, but I suppose there is a market for parents wanting their kids to have a safer place to watch clips without fear of something inappropriate coming up. I am not entirely sure if those are the types of people we should be making things for, let alone letting have kids, but that is beside the point. Disney has obviously decided — perhaps a bit too late — that the future of media is user generated content, and if they want to continue raising legions of Disney-loving children, they will have to meet them where they’re at. The part of me which used to believe the point of having these large media institutions was to serve as a bulwark against the torrent of unfettered slop American capitalism would produce without standards and practices has long since died, but I still find this so depressing. Surely Disney is aware they are entering a death pact here? If the value of having TikToks on Disney+ is that the Disney Brand Means Something, I have a feeling this may just dilute it.
The defense here is that, within the Creator Ambassador Program, Disney is sharing thousands of premium assets with TikTok and allowing approved creators to use them in their videos, without risk of a copyright strike. Of course, Disney did not create these characters, they bought them, and in the case of Marvel, they were stolen from the original artists all the way back in the 1960s. The copyright they hold of these properties does in fact give them the legal right to take down any fan video they want, but implicit in Disney’s agreement with TikTok is the admission that fan videos do quite a lot to sustain the value of Disney’s IP in the first place. As we enter an increasingly fragmented media ecosystem, where a company like Disney cannot simply release a movie in theaters and automatically take up the discourse, fan content is more valuable than ever. Though I have my pretentious qualms with calling TikTok videos labor, if they are generating money for these large corporations, then definitionally, the creators are doing work.
It is worth keeping in mind that this deal is between Disney and TikTok, not Disney and the creators. Unlike other underpaid/unpaid creatives of the past, these creators will not have any recourse if Disney screws them over — there is no HR, no employment law, no body governing this strange new world. I highly doubt creators will ever get the chance to unionize, let alone bargain for a better deal. TikTok itself is already highly exploitative to its creators, who are slaves to an opaque algorithm, receive pennies on the dollar, and can get suspended from monetization at basically any time, without warning. Not to be forgotten, Larry Ellison’s Oracle owns 15% of TikTok’s US operations, and Ellison and his son David control Skydance, which now owns Paramount and Warner Bros. There is very little doubt in my mind that Ellison would like his investment in both TikTok and the film industry to pay off, and this Disney deal is certainly just the beginning.
Ultimately, I think it is useful to consider the Disney-TikTok deal as further evidence that Hollywood’s next big IP is us. After buying everything under the sun, and finding that after only 15 or so years, they have dried the wells of IP-exploitation, their only course of action is to monetize the very act of existing. Today, GTA VI released worldwide, and seems to represent a new frontier in monocultural events. Yes, the game is quite fun and many people care about it just because they want to play it, but the reason it is such a Big Cultural Moment is more complex. GTA VI will result in millions of hours of videos where we can watch other people play the game, role-play within it, and build upon the world that Rockstar games created. All of this before the online mode even comes out, it’s no wonder the big Streaming Services are (reportedly) quite upset that they can’t get in on the gold rush. Everything is content now, forever and always. Buckle up.
Signing off,
Max Bolen
Tried to get an Editorial Internship at Marvel Comics once, and was only given an interview with a Literal Robot.



Disney are basically just flailing about at the moment